© 2002 by the American Diabetes Association, Inc. Chronic Central Melanocortin-4 Receptor Antagonism and Central Neuropeptide-Y Infusion in Rats Produce Increased Adiposity by Divergent PathwaysDiabetes Research Group, the Garvan Institute of Medical Research, Sydney, Australia
Increased hypothalamic neuropeptide-Y (NPY) action and disruption of the melanocortin (MC)-4 receptor both result in hyperphagia and obesity. To determine whether similar hormonal and metabolic mechanisms are involved in these two obesity syndromes, we investigated the time course of effects induced by 6-day intracerebroventricular (ICV) infusion of NPY (3.5 nmol/day) or the MC4 receptor antagonist HS014 (4.8 nmol/day) in rats pair-fed with vehicle-infused controls. The weight of white adipose tissue (WAT) deposits was increased after 6-day NPY and HS014 infusion compared with controls, and the increase was significantly greater in HS014- than in NPY-infused rats (retroperitoneal WAT: NPY 0.57 ± 0.05; HS014 0.80 ± 0.05; control 0.43 ± 0.03% body wt, n = 813, P < 0.05). Plasma leptin was also increased in both experimental groups (NPY 10.6 ± 1.9; HS014 4.4 ± 0.9; control 2.0 ± 0.1 ng/ml, n = 813, P < 0.05 for all comparisons). Basal plasma corticosterone and insulin levels were increased by ICV NPY infusion, whereas HS014-infused rats showed no significant increase in these parameters on any of 16 days of infusion. Both NPY and HS014 infusion potentiated intravenous glucose-induced (300 mg/kg) plasma insulin levels, and there was no difference in glycemia among groups. In NPY-infused rats, the plasma free fatty acid levels were decreased and triglyceridemia was increased compared with controls, but these parameters were unchanged in HS014-infused rats. Hepatic triglyceride content was significantly increased by HS014 but not by NPY infusion. Levels of uncoupling protein-1 mRNA in brown adipose tissue were significantly decreased after 6 days of HS014 infusion, similar to the effect of central NPY. Because ICV HS014 induced at least as great an increase in fat mass as ICV NPY and yet had divergent hormonal and metabolic effects, we conclude that MC4 receptor antagonism does not induce obesity solely by regulation of the endogenous NPY-ergic system.
Neuropeptide-Y (NPY) is a highly potent orexigenic peptide synthesized in the brain (1). Genetically obese ob/ob and db/db mice and fa/fa rats exhibit a lack of leptin function as their primary defect (2,3,4,5), and all exhibit increased NPY expression and secretion in the hypothalamus (6) caused by a lack of leptins known inhibitory effect on NPY-ergic activity (7). Although other peptides are likely to be involved (1), this increase in hypothalamic NPY probably contributes to obesity in ob/ob, db/db, and fa/fa rodents because intracerebroventricular (ICV) infusions of NPY in normal rodents produce effects similar to those seen in the genetically obese rodent models. These include increased food intake, body weight, fat accumulation, plasma insulin, leptin, and corticosterone concentrations, decreased brown adipose tissue (BAT) thermogenesis, and inhibition of the somatotropic and gonadotropic axes (8,9,10,11,12). Several dominant mutations at the agouti locus in the mouse also cause a syndrome of marked obesity, hyperinsulinemia, insulin resistance, and hyperglycemia (13,14,15). Antagonism of the hypothalamic melanocortin (MC)-4 receptor by ectopically expressed agouti is probably the cause of the agouti mouse obesity syndrome (16), because MC4 receptor knockout mice have an obesity syndrome identical to that of the agouti obese mouse (17). Agouti-related protein (AgRP), a high affinity endogenous antagonist of the MC3 and MC4 receptor (18,19), is probably involved in energy homeostasis, because hypothalamic AgRP expression is increased in fasting rats (20,21), and ICV AgRP infusions stimulate food intake in both starved and satiated rats (22,23). So far, little is known about the mechanisms and primary etiological causes of obesity in agouti mice and MC4 receptor knockout mice. Studies involving central administration of exogenous MC4 receptor antagonists have focused primarily on effects of feeding, and little is known about the effect that chronic MC4 receptor antagonism has on the peripheral hormonal and metabolic parameters known to alter energy homeostasis or the time-course of these effects. Long-term administration of the MC4 receptor antagonist HS014 has been reported to increase food intake and consequently increase body weight and adiposity (24). Additionally, chronic administration of the MC4 receptor antagonist SHU911 in rats allowed to eat ad libitum resulted in increased food intake, adiposity, plasma corticosterone, insulin, and leptin, with no changes in plasma growth hormone, insulin-like growth factor-1, leutenizing hormone, follicle-stimulating hormone, and testosterone (25). These observed effects could be a result of increased food intake, and currently no studies have observed the sequential hormonal and metabolic effects after chronic MC4 receptor antagonism in rats where increased food intake is prevented. There is some evidence that the mechanisms contributing to obesity in genetically obese ob/ob and fa/fa rodents (which exhibit early onset obesity, early onset hyperinsulinemia, decreased linear growth, and elevated levels of plasma corticosterone) are in some ways different to the etiology of obesity in agouti and MC4 receptor knockout mice (which exhibit late-onset obesity, late-onset hyperinsulinemia, increased linear growth, and no effects on basal plasma corticosterone levels) (13,14). On the contrary, other available evidence suggests that chronic central MC4 receptor antagonism induces obesity at least partially via the NPY-ergic system (26). Agouti obese mice exhibit increased levels of NPY mRNA in the dorsomedial nucleus (27). Furthermore, the orexigenic effects of the specific MC4 receptor antagonist HS014 were partially inhibited by an NPY-Y1 receptor antagonist (28) and completely blocked by fluoxetine, which inhibits NPY release (29,30). Therefore, the available literature provides conflicting evidence as to whether MC4 receptor antagonism induces obesity and any hormonal and metabolic changes via actions on the endogenous NPY-ergic system. To determine whether similar pathways are involved in the obesity syndromes induced by chronic central NPY-ergic activation and chronic MC4 receptor antagonism, we compared the hormonal and metabolic effects of 6-day ICV NPY or MC4 receptor antagonist (HS014) infusion in normal rats. All rats were pair-fed with vehicle-infused controls in order to study the effects of NPY and HS014 in the absence of their known hyperphagic effects (8,28).
Experimental animals. All procedures were approved by the Animal Experimentation Ethics Committee of the Garvan Institute/St Vincents Hospital and are in keeping with the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australias guidelines on animal experimentation. Male Wistar rats were purchased from Animal Resources Center (Perth, Australia) at weights of 250280 g. They were housed in groups in plastic cages on pellet paper bedding and under conditions of controlled temperature (23°C) and illumination (06001800). They were allowed ad libitum access to standard laboratory diet (Norco Stockfeeds, South Lismore, Australia) and water, unless otherwise stated.
Placement of chronic ICV and jugular cannulae.
Acute ICV injection of NPY and HS014.
Chronic ICV infusion of NPY and HS014.
Tissue collection from NPY- and HS014-infused rats.
BAT uncoupling protein-1 mRNA analysis.
Liver analysis.
Statistics.
Dose of NPY and HS014. To standardize the biological potency of NPY and HS014, we chose doses of these compounds that produce similar and maximal degrees of hyperphagia in ad libitumfed rats. After acute ICV injection of a maximum dose of NPY (1.2 nmol) (32), rats consumed sevenfold as much diet as vehicle-injected rats in the ensuing 4 h (Fig. 1). A similar 4-h food intake was obtained after ICV injection of 1.5 nmol of HS014 (Fig. 1), and higher doses did not produce greater hyperphagia (data not shown). For chronic infusion studies, three times this maximally effective acute dose was infused over each 24-h period as previously described for NPY (11). Because all animals were fed the same amount as vehicle-infused controls during chronic infusions, latency to feed was used as an index of biological potency of NPY and HS014. In both NPY- and HS014-infued rats, latency to feed was <30 s on each of days 26 of infusion compared with >60 s in vehicle-infused controls (data not shown). If the latency to feed was >30 s, animals were excluded from the NPY- or HS014-infused groups (<10% of rats).
Body weight and adiposity of NPY- and HS014-infused rats. There was no significant difference among NPY-, HS014-, and saline-infused rats with respect to body weight before infusion (NPY 354 ± 8, HS014 372 ± 7, and control 367 ± 6 g, n = 916, NS) or with respect to body weight gain during the 6 days of infusion (Fig. 2A). This is consistent with data showing that whereas chronic ICV NPY or MC4 receptor antagonist infusion significantly increases body weight in ad libitumfed rats (8,24,25,33), no such increase is observed when hyperphagia is prevented by pair-feeding with vehicle-infused controls (11,33,34). However, 6 days of central infusion of NPY or HS014 with pair-feeding to control rats significantly increased fat accumulation in the epididymal and retroperitoneal white adipose tissue (WAT) depots compared with saline-infused controls (Fig. 2B). Furthermore, the retroperitoneal fat depot weight was significantly greater in HS014-infused than in NPY-infused rats (Fig. 2B). The 6 days of ICV infusion of both NPY and HS014 resulted in significant increases in plasma leptin levels compared with controls, but the effect was significantly greater in NPY-infused rats than in rats infused with HS014 (Fig. 2C).
Plasma corticosterone, insulin, and glucose levels during chronic ICV NPY or HS014 infusions. The plasma concentrations of corticosterone during the 6 days of ICV infusion are shown in Fig. 3A. Compared with the vehicle-infused control rats, pair-fed NPY-infused rats had an increase in plasma corticosterone levels during the first 2 days of infusion. In contrast, long-term ICV infusion of the MC4 receptor antagonist HS014 with pair-feeding to control rats had no significant effect on corticosteronemia at any time point. NPY-infused rats exhibited significantly greater plasma insulin levels compared with control and HS014-infused rats over the 6 days of central infusion (Fig. 3B). Rats chronically ICV-infused with HS014 exhibited no significant difference from control values in plasma insulin levels over the 6 days of infusion (Fig. 3B). Levels of glycemia were not significantly changed from control values in ICV NPY- or HS014-infused rats (Fig. 3C).
Plasma insulin and glucose levels after intravenous glucose injection. Immediately before glucose injection, basal insulinemia was greater than control values in NPY- but not HS014-infused rats (Fig. 4A). Intravenous glucose-induced plasma insulin levels were more elevated than control values for both NPY- and HS014-infused rats at 1 and 5 min postglucose injection (Fig. 4A), and the difference was significant at 5 min. The incremental areas under the insulin curves shown in Fig. 4 are NPY 3,960 ± 440, P = 0.08 vs. control; HS014 5,130 ± 330, P < 0.001 vs. control; and control 2,750 ± 470 pmol/l x 5 min, with no significant difference between NPY- and HS014-infused rats. Plasma glucose levels of NPY- and HS014-infused rats were no different from control values either before or at any time after glucose injection (Fig. 4B).
Plasma lipid concentrations during chronic ICV NPY or HS014 infusion. The plasma concentrations of free fatty acids (FFAs) and TGs are shown in Fig. 5. Plasma FFA levels in NPY-infused rats were significantly reduced compared with saline and HS014-infused rats for the first 3 days of ICV infusion (Fig. 5A). Plasma FFA levels in HS014-infused rats were not significantly different from control levels for the entire 6 days of infusion (Fig. 5A). Plasma TG levels of NPY-infused rats were significantly elevated compared with control and HS014-infused rats on days 15 of central infusion (Fig. 5B). Plasma TG levels of HS014-infused rats were not significantly different relative to controls during the infusion period (Fig. 5B).
Liver TG content after chronic ICV NPY or HS014 infusion. Hepatic TG content was significantly increased over control values in HS014- but not NPY-infused rats (Fig. 5C). There was no significant difference among the three groups with respect to liver weight after 56 days of infusion (NPY 13.2 ± 0.3, HS014 12.6 ± 0.5, and control 12.0 ± 0.3 g, n = 48, NS).
BAT weight and UCP-1 mRNA levels after chronic ICV NPY or HS014 infusion.
This work investigated whether aspects of the obesity syndromes induced by chronically increased NPY-ergic activity or central MC4 receptor antagonism are mediated by independent or common pathways. To this end, we compared the time course of hormono-metabolic consequences of chronic ICV infusion of NPY and HS014 (an analogue of the endogenous MC3/MC4 receptor antagonist AgRP) in rats, where hyperphagia had been prevented by pair-feeding. It was demonstrated that 6 days of central infusion of either NPY or HS014 in rats resulted in significant increases in WAT mass, even though NPY- and HS014-infused rats were prevented from overeating by pair-feeding with vehicle-infused control rats. As with another very recent study using 7-day ICV AgRP injections (33), we demonstrated that MC4 receptor antagonist-infused rats show an increase in WAT mass in the absence of increased food intake. Our study also extends this observation by making a direct comparison of the effects of central HS014 infusion with those of NPY and by time course comparison of endocrine and metabolic effects. Because ICV HS014 induced at least as great an increase in fat mass as ICV NPY and yet had divergent hormonal and metabolic effects, we conclude that MC4 receptor antagonism does not induce obesity solely by regulation of the endogenous NPY-ergic system. Because plasma concentrations of leptin are positively correlated with percent body fat (35), increased plasma leptin levels in NPY- and HS014-infused rats probably reflected the increased adiposity. However, plasma leptin levels of rats infused with the MC4 receptor antagonist HS014 were significantly lower than those of NPY-infused rats, even though adiposity in the HS014 group was at least as great. A similar outcome was recently reported in comparison of effects of ICV SHU9119 and NPY in ad libitumfed rats (25). This highlights the fact that leptinemia is regulated by many factors besides fat mass (35). Corticosterone and insulin, plasma levels of which were shown to be increased in NPY- but not HS014-infused rats, are both known to positively regulate plasma leptin levels (35). Additionally, other researchers have shown that plasma testosterone levels are significantly reduced by NPY but not by SHU9119 infusion (12,25), and because testosterone is an inhibitor of leptin secretion (35), this difference may also contribute to the lower plasma leptin levels of the HS014 group. It has recently been reported that chronic central infusion of the MC3/MC4 receptor antagonist SHU9119 increased plasma corticosterone levels in ad libitumfed rats (25). This effect was probably mediated by SHU9119-induced hyperphagia because feeding is known to increase corticosteronemia (36), and because in the present study MC4 receptor antagonist infusion with concomitant pair-feeding caused no such hypercorticosteronemia. Our finding is in keeping with reports that animal models with chronic MC4 receptor antagonism, such as MC4 receptor knockout mice and agouti obese yellow mice, do not have elevated basal plasma corticosterone levels (17). High plasma levels of insulin are known to contribute to obesity because attenuation of the hyperinsulinemia of genetically obese rodents (37,38) reduced the obese phenotype in the absence of significant effects on feeding. Furthermore, administration of exogenous insulin to animals and humans results in increased fat accumulation and other metabolic defects characteristic of obesity (39,40,41). NPY-infused rats exhibited two- to threefold increases over controls in basal plasma insulin levels over the infusion period. This hyperinsulinemia, in addition to reduced thermogenesis (9,42,43,44,45), is the likely primary mechanism by which NPY-infused rats become obese in the absence of hyperphagia. In contrast to the NPY-infused group, rats that received HS014 infusions did not exhibit any significant change in insulinemia relative to control rats, indicating that hyperinsulinemia may not be the only contributor to the observed increase in adiposity. Glucose-stimulated plasma insulin concentrations were elevated in both NPY- and HS014-infused rats in the absence of any difference from controls in glycemia, an indication of insulin resistance. This increased insulin response to glucose in both obesity models may be mediated by insulin resistance, which is commonly observed in situations of increased fat mass, as in ICV NPY-infused rats (11). Therefore, the late-onset hyperinsulinemia observed in MC4 receptor knockout and agouti obese yellow mice is unlikely to result from a primary defect in insulin secretion, and hyperinsulinemia probably develops secondary to insulin resistance. In addition to the hormonal differences discussed above, differences in metabolic profiles were also observed between ICV NPY- and MC4 receptor antagonist-induced increases in adiposity, suggesting independent etiologies. Whereas central NPY infusion significantly reduced plasma FFA and increased plasma TG levels (possibly mediated by hyperinsulinemia and/or reduced sympathetic nervous activity), the plasma concentrations of FFAs and TGs in HS014-infused rats were not significantly different from controls, reflective of the unchanged plasma insulin profile. Unlike NPY-infused rats, the total liver TG content observed in rats infused with HS014 was increased relative to controls, despite no change in tissue weight. It is well established that central NPY administration decreases sympathetically mediated thermogenic activity in BAT (9,42,43,44,45), most likely by decreasing the expression of UCP-1 (9). This effect is likely to contribute to NPY-induced obesity because BAT ablation per se also results in an obesity syndrome (46). This study has shown that UCP-1 mRNA levels are also decreased in BAT after 6 days of central MC4 receptor antagonism with HS014, extending a recent report that 7-day ICV AgRP injection with pair-feeding decreased the levels of UCP-1 protein in BAT (33). Furthermore, the extent of BAT UCP-1 mRNA downregulation in HS014-infused rats was at least as great as that induced by 6-day ICV NPY infusion. Recently, it was reported that ICV NPY infusion or antagonism of central MC3 and MC4 receptors with AgRP could reduce the plasma levels of thyroid-stimulating hormone and T4 (33,47,48). Reduced thyroid function could reduce whole-body energy expenditure and contribute to increased energy retention as fat. The heterogeneity of hormonal and metabolic consequences of central NPY infusion or MC4 receptor antagonism shown in this study are supported by a recent comparison of brain sites of c-Fos activation in response to NPY or the MC3/MC4 receptor antagonist AgRP-(83132) (49). c-Fos immunoreactivity was significantly increased over control values in the hypothalamic PVN of both NPY- and AgRP-injected rats, measured at 2 h after ICV injection. In contrast, only NPY significantly increased c-Fos activation in the NTS at this time point, although AgRP did produce a lesser degree of c-Fos activation in this site at 24 h after injection. Only AgRP resulted in significantly increased c-Fos immunoreactivity in the accumbens shell and the lateral septum (49). The PVN is implicated as a site regulating BAT thermogenesis (9) and activity of the thyrotropic axis (48), whereas the NTS is implicated in mediation of NPY-induced insulin secretion (50). Collectively, these data fit the hypothesis that both NPY and MC receptor antagonism reduce thyroid function (47,48) and BAT UCP-1 expression by effects on the PVN, yet only NPY has significant effects on basal hyperinsulinemia, mediated by neuronal activation in the NTS. In conclusion, the differences in hormonal and metabolic perturbations that develop during the early stages of ICV NPY and HS014 infusions, using doses that produce similar increases in adiposity, suggest that NPY and MC4 receptor antagonism induce increases in fat mass via at least partially divergent pathways. In the NPY obesity model, hypercorticosteronemia and hyperinsulinemia are early onset factors. In contrast, the increase in adiposity induced by chronic central MC4 receptor antagonism does not appear to involve hypercorticosteronemia or basal hyperinsulinemia. However, it is likely that the etiology of both obesity models involves increased glucose-induced insulin secretion, possibly secondary to increased fat mass and insulin resistance, and downregulation of BAT UCP-1 mRNA expression, which may be mediated by changes in thyroid function as recently reported (33,47,48).
The National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia has supported this work via a Center Grant to the Garvan Institute and a postdoctoral fellowship awarded to A. Sainsbury (Peter Doherty Fellowship 987122). We thank Dr. Herbert Herzog, Marjorie Liu, Michelle Couzens, and Elizabeth Smith (Garvan Institute, Sydney, Australia) for provision of the UCP-1 and GAPDH probes and help with Northern analysis. We thank Dr. Julie Ferguson and Dr. Jenny Kingham for their invaluable veterinary advice and the staff of the Garvan Institute Biological Testing Facility.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. A. Sainsbury, Diabetes Research Group, the Garvan Institute of Medical Research, 384 Victoria St., Darlinghurst NSW 2010, Sydney, Australia. E-mail: a.sainsbury-salis{at}garvan.org.au. Received for publication 23 February 2001 and accepted in revised form 22 October 2001. AgRP, agouti-related protein; BAT, brown adipose tissue; FFA, free fatty acid; GAPDH, glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase; ICV, intracerebroventricular; MC, melanocortin; NPY, neuropeptide-Y; NTS, nucleus tractus solitarius; PVN, paraventricular nucleus; TG, triglyceride; UCP-1, uncoupling protein-1; WAT, white adipose tissue.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||