Paradigm Shift or Shifting Paradigm for Type 1 Diabetes
- Barbara Davis Center for Childhood Diabetes, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado
- Corresponding author: George S. Eisenbarth, .
The age of onset of type 1A diabetes is now immunologically predictable (1). Either because of a lack of sufficient understanding of the pathogenesis of type 1A (immune-mediated) diabetes or a lack of effective therapeutics directed at relevant pathogenic pathways (or both), we cannot yet prevent this disease (2). The article by Liu et al. (3) in this issue of Diabetes addresses both issues in a rat model of autoimmune diabetes (Lew.1WR1). In this genetically susceptible model, multiple viral infections or a viral RNA chemical mimic (poly-IC) activate the innate immune system leading to insulitis and β-cell destruction (4). The viruses do not appear to target islets; rather, they act by inducing inflammation such that anti-inflammatory therapy (e.g., prednisone) at the time of infection prevents diabetes (5). This model was discovered when the Kilham rat virus spontaneously infected a colony of “normal” rats with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and dominant diabetes susceptibility loci on chromosome 4 (Iddm 14) (6). The iddm14 locus encompasses the family of T-cell receptor Vβ segment genes, and in particular, a specific Vβ13 haplotype is associated with diabetes susceptibility (7). Specific T cells can be targeted by monoclonals to their Vβ sequences to prevent disease.
Liu et al. analyzed the percentage and sequences of T cells with Vβ13 in islets of the rat model described above and tested whether a monoclonal antibody to Vβ13 could prevent diabetes. T cells express T-cell receptors (TCRs) composed of two chains (α and β) that recognize peptide-MHC complexes. The TCR α- and β-chain genes (Tcra and Tcrb) contain elements called Vα and Jα (α-chain) and Vβ, Dβ, and Jβ (β-chain). Individual T cells have different α- and β-chains created by recombination of these gene segments. Six complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) molecularly interact with a peptide and an MHC molecule presenting the peptide, and CDR1a, CDR2a, CDR1b, and CDR2b are germline-encoded in the Vα/β element. Each germline-encoded element sequence has a unique number (e.g., Vβ13), and all Vβ13 T cells have identical amino acid sequences including CDR1 and CDR2.
Liu et al. found that triggering of anti-islet autoimmunity in Lew.1WR1 rats induced a significant increase of Vβ13 CD4 T cells within islets. They also found significant skewing of Jβ utilization by T cells invading islets, but those T cells invading islets had a number of different CDR3 sequences. CDR3 as compared with CDR1 and CDR2 has extra sequence diversity due the joining of sequence elements at CDR3. Confirming the importance of Vβ13 (CDR1 and CDR2 sequences in particular) a monoclonal antibody targeting Vβ13 prevented diabetes in both the Lew.1WR1 model and the spontaneous BBDP rat (3,8).
The NOD mouse model also has an invariant germline encoded CDR1 and CDR2 sequence associated with autoimmune diabetes. In the NOD mouse, an insulin B-chain 9–23 peptide (insulin B:9–23) is preferentially recognized by T cells expressing a specific Vα sequence (TRAV5D-4) (9). A single mutation of this peptide (B16:alanine replacing B16:tyrosine) prevents NOD diabetes (10). Multiple murine TRAV5D-4 containing TCR α-chain sequences can induce anti-insulin autoimmunity and, in a subset of mice, diabetes (9,11). Thus for both rats and mice, TCR Vα/β germline-encoded sequences may be critical for the development of autoimmune diabetes.
Nevertheless, linkage of diabetes to TCR loci has not been demonstrated in either the NOD mouse or in humans (12,13). If similar to the Lew.1WR1 model above, either interactions between MHC alleles and V segment sequences have not been studied in enough detail, or critical TCR-germline sequences are not polymorphic. In the latter case, the TCR sequences may contribute to “species” diabetes susceptibility rather than individual susceptibility. Multiple genetic polymorphisms contribute to individual diabetes risk through effects on maintenance of general tolerance (12) and specific organ targeting (MHC alleles  and insulin promoter polymorphisms). Similar to the rat model described above, environmental factors may trigger islet autoimmunity as well as set basal population risk (15,16).
Given the findings of Liu et al., two immediate questions arise. What are the sequences of the α-chain of islet invading Vβ13 T cells? What is the target peptide of these Vβ13 bearing T cells? We assume there will be a single dominant peptide recognized by the Vβ13 CD4 T cells. One wants to know not only the sequence of the target peptide, but also its register. That is, how it binds in the MHC groove in which it is recognized (17). Once this is known, it should be possible to create fluorescent tetramers (MHC + peptide) to identify the autoreactive T cells, similar to what has been accomplished for anti-B:9–23 T cells of NOD mice (18). The paradigm that limited germline-encoded T-cell receptor sequences contribute to autoimmune diabetes susceptibility shifts emphasis to invariant sequences of CDR1 and CDR2 of α- and β-chains as essential to pathogenesis. Detailed knowledge of targets and multiple animal models will permit these paradigms to be tested and their therapeutic implications explored. A critical need is the molecular/structural characterization of relevant human anti-islet trimolecular (MHC: peptide: TCR) complexes (19) including relevant TCR sequences.
Finally, conserved T-cell receptor elements are only one part of the trimolecular complex that can be targeted to develop novel therapeutics (Fig. 1). Small molecules that bind to pockets of diabetogenic MHC alleles (20) and antibodies that react specifically with MHC with bound peptide (21) provide additional therapeutic pathways. There has been skepticism regarding development of therapeutics directed at the trimolecular complex because it has not been accomplished for any diseases in humans. To quote from the fascinating article by Liu et al.: “We recognize that, based on human and mouse data, it has been assumed that redundancy among cognate rat TCRs would preclude reliance on any one allele of TCR α- or β-chains for disease susceptibility. Our data and data of others strongly suggest that this assumption may be faulty.”
This work was supported by grants from the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (R00 DK080885 and P30 DK057516), the National Institutes of Health Autoimmune Prevention Center (U19 AI050864), the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (4-2007-1056, 44-2008-913, and 17-2010-744), and the Helmsley Foundation (09AG-118600).
G.S.E. is on two University provisional patents for treating islet autoimmunity targeting MHC-peptide complex with small molecules or antibodies and has research grant from Novartis in the same area. M.N. is on a University provisional patent for treating islet autoimmunity targeting MHC-peptide complex with small molecules. No other potential conflicts of interest relevant to this article were reported.
- © 2012 by the American Diabetes Association.
Readers may use this article as long as the work is properly cited, the use is educational and not for profit, and the work is not altered. See http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ for details.